Donna Fay Schatz

Date Found: May 8, 1980

Location: Grand Lake, Oklahoma

Investigating Agency: Delaware County Sheriff’s Office

(918) 253-4531

Donna Fay Schatz’s body was found tied to a concrete block in Grand Lake near Jay, Oklahoma by fishermen on May 10, 1981. It was determined she had been shot 10 times in the head and chest. The fisherman who found her said that the block had been tied around her leg twice with barbed wire in efforts to weigh her body down. 

Donna Fay had been associated with members of a motorcycle gang, The Outlaws, run out of Oklahoma City. It was suspected she was a drug courier for the gang who transported drugs from Cocoa Beach, Florida and Oklahoma City. 

A drug raid involving 5 people was performed after an 8-month long narcotics investigation into a drug ring being run out of a home in Belleville, Illinois. Members of The Outlaws traveled back and forth from the home and Oklahoma City. 

Three people were arrested during the raid and a fourth person was shot by police after the fact. A few days after the raid, Robert Love was found shot in the back along Illinois Route 15 outside of Belleville. Robert was confirmed to have been in the Belleville home before the raid occurred.  President of the Oklahoma chapter of The Outlaws, Scott “Little Wolf” Killip, a known associate of Donna Fay had also been arrested at the drug raid. 

Little else is known about Donna Fay and the circumstances surrounding her murder. If you or anyone you know has any information about the murder of Donna Fay Schatz, please contact the Delaware County Sheriff’s Office at (918) 253-4531.