James Crawley and Shelia McCoy

Date Found: March 13, 1998

Location: Oklahoma City

Investigating Agency: Oklahoma City Police Department (405) 297-1180

On March 13, 1998, in Oklahoma City, OK, firefighters discovered the bodies of a 52-year-old James Crawley, and a 44-year-old Shelia McCoy, were found inside a burning upholstery shop at 3663 N. Everest Avenue. Both victims were bound and gagged.

James was shot in the head with a shotgun, while Sheila was shot in the back and neck. Both bodies were doused in gasoline and set on fire.

James was a well-respected bail bondsman who owned Crawley Bail Bonds at 718 NE 36th in OKC. He also detailed cars and owned and upholstered furniture in the shop where they were found. Shelia was an employee of the shop.

It has been 26 years of no answers. Both James’ and Sheila’s family deserve answers. If you have any information regarding the murders of McCoy and Crawley, please call the OKC PD 405-297-1180. You can also submit a tip anonymously to your local law enforcement agency.