Charlene Marie Reynolds
Date Found: October 31, 1960
Location: Tahlequah, Oklahoma
Investigating Agency: Cherokee County Sheriff’s Office
(918) 456-2583
Forty year old Charlene Marie Reynolds was murdered on October 31, 1960 in Tahlequah. She had been working at the Red Oak Tavern when she was attacked. She was beaten in the head with a cast iron skillet before being stabbed six times.